Top 5 Puzzle Stores in New York City
New York City is full of puzzles! From iconic toy stores to up-and-coming puzzle brands, NYC has it all.
FAO Schwarz
An iconic toy store with a history dating back to 1862, FAO Schwarz carries a huge range of Ravensburger puzzles including Disney Princess kids puzzles, 3D landmark puzzles, and an impressive 18,000-piece challenge puzzle. A must-visit destination for puzzle lovers of all ages.
CAMP
CAMP offers unique rotating themed experiences and works with Disney for exclusive and limited-edition toys and puzzles. Their online shop stocks popular puzzle brands including Galison, Mudpuppy, and Ridley's, making it a great spot for finding something truly special.
Mary Arnold Toys
Mary Arnold Toys holds the distinction of being the longest continuously open toy store in New York City. Their puzzle selection is focused mostly on children, featuring wooden puzzles with pegged pieces and sound puzzles — a wonderful destination for families looking for quality, classic toys.
Kidding Around
Voted Best Indie Toy Store in NYC by New York Magazine, Kidding Around carries a large range of puzzles for all ages. Their selection includes wooden children's puzzles (dinosaur alphabet, farm animals), adult puzzles, roll-up puzzle mats, and adjustable puzzle boards. They also carry Jellycat, LEGO, and Brio.
Playing Mantis
Founded in 2006 by Imelda McCain, Playing Mantis in Tribeca specializes in high-quality handmade and educational toys. Their puzzle selection features charming wooden animal-shaped puzzles pairing baby animals with their parents — a wonderful find for families with young children.