Mary Arnold Toys
Phone: (212) 744‑8510
Website: maryarnoldtoys.com
Hours:
Mon‑Sat: 9:30 AM ‑ 6:00 PM
Sun: 11:00 AM ‑ 5:00 PM
Mary Arnold Toys is a treasured Upper East Side institution that has been serving New York City families since 1938. One of the oldest independent toy stores in Manhattan, this Lexington Avenue landmark has earned its enduring reputation through a carefully curated selection of classic and contemporary toys, games, and educational items — all chosen with genuine care for quality and creativity.
Puzzles have always been a strong part of Mary Arnold's inventory, ranging from beautifully designed options for children to sophisticated choices for adults. The experienced, knowledgeable staff are exceptional at matching customers with the right puzzle or toy, making every visit feel personal. Mary Arnold Toys is the kind of beloved neighborhood institution that makes New York City special.
Too many puzzles piling up in your closet?
If your shelves are overflowing but you're still craving that 'just one more' puzzle fix, you're not alone. That's where Completing the Puzzle comes in. A subscription that lets you enjoy new puzzles without the clutter. You solve, return, and repeat!
Learn more