Great places to buy puzzles in Indiana.

Indiana Stores by City

Indianapolis

Family Ties Games

Family Time Games is a locally owned game store in Indianapolis that encourages families and friends to spend quality time together through gaming. The store offers a wide variety of games, from classic board games to miniature tabletop strategy games and role-playing games. While their primary focus is on these games, they also offer a selection of puzzles that align with their mission to promote critical thinking and problem-solving skills.

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/FTGINDY/photos

The Game Preserve

The Game Preserve in Indianapolis is a locally owned game store dedicated to providing a wide variety of tabletop games, including board games, card games, and miniatures. The store offers a welcoming environment for gamers of all ages and skill levels, featuring a spacious gaming area and hosting regular events and tournaments. While their primary focus is on these games, they also offer a selection of puzzles that align with their commitment to providing engaging and thoughtful products for the community.

Photo Source: https://www.yelp.com/biz/the-game-preserve-indianapolis

Saltire Toys & Games

Saltire Toys & Games is a locally owned game store in Indianapolis that encourages families and friends to spend quality time together through gaming. The store offers a wide variety of games, from classic board games to miniature tabletop strategy games and role-playing games. While their primary focus is on card and board games, they also offer a selection of puzzles that align with their mission to promote critical thinking and problem-solving skills.

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/profile/100063501402914/search/?q=puzzle

Good Games

Good Games in Indianapolis is a vibrant and inclusive gaming destination in the heart of downtown. The store carries a broad selection of board games, card games, RPGs, and more, while also featuring a curated puzzle section. Their puzzle offerings blend casual fun with thematic and artistic designs, making it easy to pick up something for a relaxing evening or a creative gift. With tables available for play and a welcoming staff, Good Games feels like more than a shop, it’s a gathering place for fans of games and puzzles.

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/profile/100063656916562/search/?q=puzzle

Goodies & Giggles

Goodies & Giggles is a delightful toy and gift shop located in the heart of Indianapolis on Massachusetts Avenue. The store carries a range of toys, games, art supplies, books, and puzzles, making it a fun destination for kids and adults alike. Their puzzle selection often features whimsical or themed designs that fit right into their playful, creative vibe. With a cozy layout and friendly staff, Goodies & Giggles invites visitors to browse, explore, and find something to spark imagination.

Photo Source: https://www.instagram.com/goodiesandgigglestoystore/

Gray Gauntlet Games

Gray Gauntlet Games is a community-driven game store located in the Indianapolis area, catering to fans of trading card games, board games, roleplaying games, miniatures, and more. Their inventory includes Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon, Warhammer, and a broad selection of hobby supplies. Though puzzles are not their primary focus, the shop occasionally offers puzzle sets that appeal to tabletop fans, especially thematic or geek-style puzzles. Whether you're browsing cards or looking for a new game night challenge, the store’s environment is welcoming and geared toward discovery.

Photo Source: https://graygauntletgames.com/search?page=1&q=puzzle

Fort Wayne

Summit Comics & Games

Summit Comics & Games in Fort Wayne, IN, is a local favorite for comic book fans, board gamers, and puzzle enthusiasts. The store carries a wide selection of jigsaw puzzles alongside comics, tabletop games, and collectibles. Customers can find puzzles ranging from simple 500-piece designs to more challenging sets, all in a friendly and welcoming environment. Summit’s knowledgeable staff makes it easy to find the perfect puzzle for any skill level.

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/profile/100063499453068/search/?q=puzzles

United Art & Education

United Art & Education in Fort Wayne, IN, is a top destination for artists, educators, and puzzle lovers. The store offers a wide range of jigsaw puzzles alongside art supplies, educational toys, and creative materials. Customers can find puzzles for all ages and skill levels, from simple designs to more challenging sets. The friendly staff are always ready to help you select the perfect puzzle or creative resource.

Photo Source: https://www.yelp.com/biz/united-art-and-education-fort-wayne-2

FYE

FYE in Fort Wayne, IN, is a go-to destination for music, movies, collectibles, and pop culture merchandise. The store carries a variety of items, including DVDs, vinyl records, Funko Pop! figures, and jigsaw puzzles. Customers can find puzzles featuring pop culture themes, classic movies, and scenic designs for all ages. Friendly staff are available to help you find the perfect puzzle or collectible.

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/profile/100064307604797/search?q=puzzle

The Rcade

The Rcade Comics & Collectibles in Fort Wayne, IN, is a vibrant destination for comic book enthusiasts, gamers, and collectors. Located in a charming converted firehouse, the store offers a diverse selection of comics, graphic novels, Funko Pop! figures, and tabletop games. Customers can also find jigsaw puzzles featuring pop culture themes, providing a fun and engaging activity for all ages. The friendly staff is always ready to assist you in finding the perfect addition to your collection.

The Find

The Find in downtown Fort Wayne is a charming boutique offering stylish women's clothing, home décor, and unique gifts. They also carry a variety of jigsaw puzzles featuring local landmarks and scenic city views. These puzzles provide both a fun challenge and a creative way to appreciate Fort Wayne. Shoppers enjoy discovering new designs that make perfect gifts or personal keepsakes. The friendly, welcoming atmosphere makes every visit enjoyable.

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/TheRcade/

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/profile/100049970485400/search/?q=puzzle

Evansville

Bluestocking Social

Bluestocking Social is a cozy, community-oriented bookstore in Evansville that delights in offering more than just books. Among its curated inventory, you’ll find jigsaw puzzles alongside literature, art prints, and unique gifts. The shop’s welcoming atmosphere encourages browsing and discovery. Whether you’re hunting for a challenging puzzle or a beloved novel, Bluestocking Social makes the experience special.

Photo Source: https://www.shelf-awareness.com/issue.html?issue=4079#m53897

Tools 4 Teaching

Tools 4 Teaching in Evansville is a community hub for educational resources, toys, and learning tools. Among their many offerings, they carry an appealing selection of jigsaw puzzles suited for kids and adults alike. The staff are knowledgeable and eager to help you find the right puzzle or supplemental learning product. Whether you visit for classroom supplies or a new puzzle to enjoy at home, the store provides a welcoming and resourceful atmosphere.

Comic Quest

Comic Quest is a flagship comic and pop-culture store in Evansville with a wide selection of comics, graphic novels, collectibles, and puzzles. Customers find both new releases and back issues, plus related merchandise. The store’s atmosphere fosters geek culture. Comic fans, gamers, and hobbyists feel right at home. Whether you’re browsing for a rare issue or a fun puzzle, Comic Quest delivers variety and community.

Photo Source: https://www.tools4teaching.biz/

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/profile/100064197540357/search/?q=puzzle

The Vineyard

The Vineyard in Evansville is a well-established Christian retail store that carries a broad selection of faith-centered books, Bibles, music, gifts, and church supplies. Their friendly staff assist visitors in finding just the right resource, whether it’s a devotional book or a special gift. The store’s atmosphere is warm, inviting, and inclusive, making shopping a meaningful experience. As a local hub, it connects people with tools for spiritual growth.

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/profile/61569630055548/search/?q=puzzle

Your Brother’s Bookstore

Your Brother’s Bookstore is a charming independent shop in downtown Evansville that blends community spirit with curated inventory. The store stocks both new and used books across genres, along with board games, gifts, and geek culture gear. It’s the kind of place where you can wander the shelves and strike up a conversation with staff about your next read. With its warm atmosphere, it offers more than retail, it’s a gathering spot for readers and creators.

The Book Broker

The Book Broker in Evansville is a beloved local bookstore offering a diverse selection of used books, vinyl records, comic books, sports cards, and collectible games. Whether you're searching for a rare edition, a nostalgic vinyl, or the latest comic release, the store provides a welcoming atmosphere for all enthusiasts. With its extensive inventory and knowledgeable staff, The Book Broker caters to a wide range of interests, making it a must-visit destination for collectors and casual readers alike.

Photo Source: https://yourbrothersbookstore.com/