Great places to buy puzzles in Colorado.

Colorado Stores by City

Denver

Beyond the Blackboard

Beyond the Blackboard in Denver is a charming neighborhood toy and game shop with a carefully curated selection of items for kids and adults alike. Among the board games, STEM toys, art supplies, and gifts, you’ll almost always find a display of jigsaw puzzles. Their staff are helpful and often willing to recommend puzzle styles based on theme, difficulty, or interest. It’s a welcoming place to browse and discover puzzles you might not see in big box retailers.

Photo Source: https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/beyond-the-blackboard-denver

Timbuk Toys

Timbuk Toys is a locally owned toy retailer in Denver with multiple locations, each offering curated selections of educational toys, games, gifts, and yes, jigsaw puzzles. The stores tend to carry puzzles from well-known brands as well as some more artisanal or specialty puzzle offerings. You’ll find simple children’s puzzles, scene puzzles, and more challenging ones, depending on stock. The friendly staff are helpful if you’re looking for something specific, making it fun to browse.

Photo Source: https://timbuk-toys-university-hills-plaza.wheree.com/

The Wizard’s Chest

The Wizard’s Chest is a landmark specialty store in Denver mixing fantasy, games, costumes, toys, and more. Among their extensive collection of board games, role-playing gear, and costume accessories, they also carry jigsaw puzzles. The layout, two full floors, makes puzzle browsing fun because puzzles are just one of many “hidden gems” scattered among games and magic kits. Staff are knowledgeable and often help customers pick puzzle styles based on interest or challenge level.

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/TheWizardsChest/

Talulah Jones

Talulah Jones is a charming lifestyle boutique in Denver known for its curated collection of gifts, children’s toys, books, and whimsical home décor. Among their offerings you’ll also find jigsaw puzzles, especially ones that lean toward imaginative, artist-designed, or cloth/wooden elements. The store places emphasis on eco-friendly, safe, and thoughtfully made items, which often influences the puzzle selection. Shopping here feels like stepping into a magical little world. Puzzles tend to be nestled among books and toys rather than in a separate rack.

Photo Source: https://www.talulahjones.com/

Tattered Cover Book Store

Tattered Cover Book Store is more than a bookstore, it’s a Denver institution with cozy spaces, cafés, and a wide selection of books, gifts, and community events. Among its curated inventory, you’ll often find jigsaw puzzles tucked in with gifts, games, or in the books section. The Colfax location especially has space to browse, linger, and discover puzzles you might not see elsewhere. The staff are helpful, making recommendations if you tell them what kind of imagery, piece count, or difficulty you like.

Photo Source: https://www.tatteredcover.com/

Peak-A-Boo Toys

Peak-A-Boo Toys is a whimsical toy store located in Denver’s vibrant McGregor Square, where families and gift seekers alike will find a curated mix of toys, games, plush, and puzzles. The shop is known for its playful and modern atmosphere, making it fun to browse whether you’re shopping for children or something special for yourself. Jigsaw puzzles are tucked into their wide-ranging selection, offering both kid-friendly options and engaging designs for adults. It’s a local favorite for discovering gifts that inspire creativity and imagination.

Photo Source: https://www.mcgregorsquare.com/retailer/peak-a-boo-toys/

Poor Richards Books, Gifts & Toy Store

Poor Richard’s is a multifaceted local favorite in Colorado Springs, part bookstore, part gift shop, part toy store, and part café/restaurant complex. The toy store (Little Richard’s) is tucked into this larger space, offering a selection of games, classic toys, and yes, jigsaw puzzles. The store’s atmosphere is warm and inviting, making browsing a pleasure, whether you’re hunting for books or toy surprises. Many shoppers like that there’s more than just toys here. The gift and book sections make it easy to explore and discover.

Colorado Springs

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/profile/100080313156263/search/?q=puzzle

Petrie’s Family Games

Petrie’s Family Games is a community-oriented game & hobby store in Colorado Springs that carries a broad mix of board games, card games, miniatures, and yes, jigsaw puzzles. The shop is warm and welcoming, making it easy for newcomers and longtime gamers alike to browse. Their events, like board game nights and Magic or Pokémon gatherings, add to the friendly atmosphere. For puzzle shoppers, there’s often a good variety tucked in among the other hobby sections.

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/profile/100063510013357/search/?q=puzzle

Odds & Ends Emporium

Odds & Ends Emporium is a cozy, creative retail shop in Colorado Springs focused on locally made gifts, décor, toys, and art. Among their quirky and beautiful offerings, you’ll often find jigsaw puzzles included in their rotating inventory. The shop’s emphasis on USA and Colorado artisans means the puzzle selection can include items you won’t see in mass chains. With its friendly, curated vibe, browsing here feels like exploring an artisan’s treasure trove.

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/profile/100070529163082/search/?q=puzzle

Westside Stories

Westside Stories is a cozy, independent bookstore nestled in Old Colorado City, Colorado Springs, offering a warm and welcoming atmosphere for book lovers. Beyond its wide selection of new and used books, the store carries thoughtful gifts, art prints, and puzzles. The staff is known for friendly, personal assistance and a passion for connecting readers with hidden gems. A visit here feels more like wandering through someone’s curated library than a typical retail shop.

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/WestsideStoriesBookstore

Rainy Day Anime

Rainy Day Anime is a vibrant specialty shop in Colorado Springs where fans can find manga, figures, plushies, apparel, and even anime-themed puzzles. The store’s eclectic selection appeals to casual shoppers and collectors alike, blending fun merchandise with harder-to-find treasures. Friendly and knowledgeable staff are always available to help track down a favorite character or recommend something new. Whether you’re shopping for a unique puzzle, the latest manga, or the perfect gift, Rainy Day Anime is a must-visit destination for anime culture.

Photo Source: https://www.facebook.com/profile/100057504825751/search?q=puzzle

Gamer’s Haven

Gamer’s Haven is a must-visit destination in Colorado Springs for tabletop gamers, puzzle lovers, and hobbyists of all kinds. The shop carries a wide variety of board games, jigsaw puzzles, miniatures, RPG systems, and collectible card games, making it easy to find something new for your collection. With demo tables and organized game nights, the store invites players and puzzlers alike to gather and enjoy their favorite pastimes. Whether you’re after a challenging puzzle or the latest tabletop release, Gamer’s Haven blends shopping with community fun.

Photo Source: https://cardstoresnearme.com/store/5642/gamers-haven

Aurora

Crit Castle Games

Crit Castle Games is a full-service hobby and game store in Aurora offering board games, miniatures, RPGs, and puzzles all under one roof. The shop’s inventory spans from staple titles to niche, specialty sets, allowing both casual and serious gamers to explore diverse genres. With open gaming nights and demo tables, the store encourages visitors to try before you buy. Whether you're picking up a puzzle for relaxation or the latest expansion for your favorite game, Crit Castle blends variety with community energy.

Photo Source: https://crit-castle-games.wheree.com/

BoxLunch

BoxLunch in Aurora is a pop culture store filled with apparel, gifts, and fandom merchandise, plus a rotating selection of themed puzzles. Shoppers will find designs inspired by anime, Marvel, Star Wars, and Disney, perfect for both fans and puzzle enthusiasts. The combination of puzzles, clothing, and collectibles makes the store a fun destination for unique finds. Whether you’re hunting for a gift or a puzzle to work on at home, BoxLunch brings fan culture to life.