2025: Top 5 Puzzle Stores in New York City
New York City is full of puzzles! From iconic toy stores to up-and-coming puzzle brands, NYC has it all. There are dozens of great places to find jigsaw puzzles in NYC, so keep reading to find out some of our favorites!
1. FAO Schwarz
We couldn’t write this blog post without acknowledging one of the most famous toy stores in the world. FAO Schwarz has been around since 1862, and with all those years of experience, they know exactly what to stock when it comes to puzzles. FAO Schwarz carries a huge range of Ravensburger puzzles, which are a fan-favorite brand. Their offerings include Disney Princess themed kids puzzles, 3D models of famous world landmarks, and even an 18,000 piece challenge!
Photo Source: https://www.instagram.com/faoschwarz/
2. CAMP
CAMP is a totally unique shopping experience that mixes display with play and has rotating themed experiences at their locations across the country. They work with big names, like Disney, to offer exclusive and limited edition toys, games, and puzzles. There are options for children and adults, so everyone can find a puzzle at this store! Their online shop is also stocked with puzzles from Galison, Mudpuppy, and Ridley’s.
Photo Source: https://camp.com/
3. Mary Arnold Toys
Located in the Upper East side, Mary Arnold Toys has the title of longest continuously open toy store in NYC. Their puzzle selection is mostly aimed at children, with many smaller piece count jigsaws. They have the classic wooden puzzles with easy to hold pegged pieces, but also carry puzzles that make sound when you put the pieces in the correct places! In addition to puzzles, they have other similar puzzle style games such as Rush Hour and Mastermind and puzzle box brain teasers.
Photo Source: https://www.instagram.com/maryarnoldtoys/
4. Kidding Around
Voted Best Indie Toy Store in NYC by New York Magazine, Kidding around has a large range of puzzles available for all ages. Their wooden children’s puzzle selection has so many fun options from dinosaur alphabet to farm animals. They also carry puzzles for adults and older children as well as puzzling accessories like roll up puzzle mats and adjustable puzzle boards. Kidding Around has non-puzzle options from well known brands like Jellycat, LEGO, and Brio.
Photo Source: https://www.instagram.com/KiddingAroundNYC/
5. Playing Mantis
Playing Mantis is a children's toy store in Tribeca, New York City. It was founded in 2006 by Imelda McCain, who wanted to create a store that offered high-quality, handmade toys that were both educational and fun. The store's inventory includes a wide variety of wooden toys, puzzles, games, and other playthings from around the world. A highlight in their collection are their wooden animal shaped puzzles. Each puzzle depicts a baby animal and their parent.
Photo Source: https://friendlymantis.com/shop/toys/puzzles/figure-puzzles/figure-puzzles-hen/#tab-description
Did we miss your favorite spot? Comment below and let us know so we can add it to our ever growing list of puzzle stores across the United States!
